Jewish Joy: an Essay by Jennifer Weiner

When I think about Jewish joy, I don’t think about the holidays I’ve hosted. It’s not the thirty or forty friends and relatives I’ve welcomed to break their Yom Kippur fast on bagels and smoked fish who come to mind. Not the gefilte fish I made from scratch with my Nana, my mom, and my daughters. Not the challah I kneaded online during COVID, to feel some connection with other Jewish women during lockdown. Not the Seders or the Shabbats, or any of the good times.

What I think about instead is the singular tragedy that unfolded after my brother Jake’s bar mitzvah.

Jake was called to the Torah on Saturday morning in 1986. On Sunday, dozens of his friends, along with relatives who’d made the trip from far and wide to our home in the Connecticut suburbs, were celebrating with a pool party in our backyard. My mom had been preparing for days, laboring over the centerpiece of the festive meal: Craig Claiborne’s leg of lamb, butterflied by the butcher and marinated for days in olive oil, rosemary and garlic.

The morning of the party, a contingent of senior citizens left early to drive to the Mystic aquarium, two hours away. They spent their day on their feet, in the hot summer sunshine, and arrived back at our house at five pm, their customary dinner hour.

Except dinner wasn’t ready yet.

My mom grilled five pounds of chicken, an alternative main course she’d prepared, mostly for cousin Rachel, who eschewed red meat. I watched as the scent of grilling chicken rose in the air, and the sunburned senior citizens began to make their way to the picnic tables, lured by the ambrosial scents of garlic, rosemary and roasting meat.

My mother arranged the chicken on a pair of platters. She carried them to the table, where the early birds were lining up with the hungry, chlorine-scented teenagers. She put the platters down…and the chicken vanished. It disappeared. It was vaporized. One minute it was there, and, the next, it was as if it had never been there at all. There was nothing but empty platters and empty plates.

My mother began to look worried…especially because her mother, my Nana, was watching the proceedings with a gimlet eye.

My mom began to slice the lamb that she’d pulled off the grill to rest. Her hands were trembling slightly as she set the rosy slices on the platters, with wedges of lemon and slices of pita, and carried it outside.

Again, the platters hit the picnic tables. The hoards descended. And, again, the food disappeared.

My Nana looked at my mom, and unscrewed her mouth long enough to deliver her verdict. “Frances,” she said, “you ran out of food!”

My mother bowed her head, acknowledging her shame and her failure. Then she pressed a wad of cash and her car keys into my hand. “Jenny,” she instructed, “go get food.”

I’d only gotten my license a few weeks earlier. I’d never driven to the supermarket alone. “What kind of food?” I asked.

“Just…food! FOOD! Any food that’s ready! Go!”

I went. I bought a dozen grinders – hoagies, in Philadelphia parlance – and prepared potato salad and cole slaw. I raced home and watched my mom throw the sandwiches, still-wrapped, toward the tables full of teenage boys, like a zookeeper tossing a bucket of chum to a school of sharks. My Nana was still shaking her head, looking at my mom as though she’d started a war. “I can’t believe this,” she said, half-addressing my mother, half-addressing the heavens. “What kind of Jewish woman runs out of food?”

That day left a mark, which anyone who’s ever visited my house for the holidays would tell you about. I routinely buy food for at least twice the number of guests I’ve invited. There will be latkes enough for a football team; enough smoked fish for a neighboring town. The ghost of Jake’s bar mitzvah, my husband will say, manfully tucking into leftovers for the third night in a row.

It’s a funny story; one that my siblings and I have been telling and re-telling for years; one that my daughters and nieces and nephew can all recite by heart.

It’s also, I think, a very Jewish story. Because what’s more Jewish than finding hilarity in a crisis, or laughing about something that’s gone a little off the rails?

I think Rebekah Lowin would agree, because I know she sees the world the way I do. “In Jewish life, the good stuff and the not-so-good stuff are frequently a package deal,” she writes. “In other words…joy doesn’t always look like one long hora.”

The hard times give you material. The bad days, the burnt bread, the overcooked kugel and the underseasoned roast all give you something; a reward that’s every bit as sustaining as a delicious meal: they give you stories to tell.

—

Did you enjoy the essay? Join us September 8th at 7:00 PM for a conversation with Rebekah Lowin and Jennifer Weiner regarding Rebekah’s new cookbook, A Year of Jewish Joy.

Categories:
Jewish Joy at The WeitzmanPrograms/Education